PDA

View Full Version : edges awards for the year

Premonition
15th Dec 2007, 12:37 PM
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=217269
The Edge Awards 2007

Best Game
SMG super mario galaxy
Runners-Up
The Orange Box
Halo 3

Best Innovation
Halo 3
Runners-Up
Crysis
Portal

Best Visual Design
Bioshock
Runners-Up
Team Fortress 2
SMG

Best Audio Design
SMG
Runners-Up
Halo 3
Colin MCrae: Dirt

Best Online Experience
Halo 3
Runners-Up
Forza 2
Wii Channels

Best Hardware
Rock Band
Runners-Up
Nintendo DS
Nintendo Wii

Best Developer
Valve
Runners-Up
Bungie
Nintendo

Best Publisher
Nintendo
Runners-Up
Microsoft
EA


Ive never read edge so i dont know how good of a source they are but since they did have different winners than spike tv i thought it would be worth mentioning. They clearly seem to love nintendo though :)
CarbonFire
15th Dec 2007, 02:16 PM
Best Innovation
Halo 3
Runners-Up
Crysis
Portal

:huh:


:lol:

I must have missed the innovative part :?
Rand{CLR}
15th Dec 2007, 02:51 PM
You also missed Halo 3 as best online experience. Seems that title belongs to COD4 this year.

Wii Channels has no business being in the discussion. Everyone Votes and Check Me Out are minor time wasters. Though Wii Virtual Console is very cool.

Some of the points made in the thread were very good, like how in the heck did Valve win "Best Hardware?" :?

-Rand
CarbonFire
15th Dec 2007, 03:54 PM
Valve won best developer, not best hardware. Harmonix's Rock Band won Best Hardware.

And it is arguable that Halo 3 has the best online experience. Theres a lot of added value there with the large number of game types, the party system, and the replay videos. I'd probably be playing it if I didn't detest the matchmaking system and the controller scheme for console FPSes so much.
Kenshin Himura
15th Dec 2007, 04:57 PM
Best Innovation
Halo 3
Runners-Up
Crysis
Portal

:huh:


:lol:

I must have missed the innovative part :?
+1
Rand{CLR}
16th Dec 2007, 12:12 AM
Valve won best developer, not best hardware. Harmonix's Rock Band won Best Hardware.

Oh, sorry. I wrote my post just after reading page 1 of the forum link from Prem, and one of the nitwits there had two "best hardware" listings instead of best developer, and I didn't go back to look at the original list.

-Rand